Examples of Evolution: Debunked Pt1

This article is going to be a little different. An evolutionist posted a list of examples of “evolution” to an evolutionary group I lurk in. While the list is hardly scientific, I’m going to take the list apart and debunk it anyway, because it is easily accessible to the layman and is thus dangerous. You will find that many of these examples are either fraudulent or equivocate on the word “evolution”. Before we go any further, I want to define a few terms from the Berkley evolution website.  This is not a creation website, it is frequently cited by evolutionists as the best place for a newcomer to science to go to learn about evolution.

UC Berkley macroevolution

UC Berkley microevolution


These three definitions are very important to keep in mind. Most of what they talk about on this list are examples of three, adaptation, but the word “Evolution” is used interchangeably for all three. No wonder the public is confused.

  1. Peppered moths

I really should write an article about the peppered moth fraud. To put it mildly, there is no “industrial melanism”. Peppered moths do not live on trunks of trees, they live in treetops. The Kettlewell experiments and those thereafter were frauds, deliberately perpetrated on the public to convince the world that evolution was occurring. Even if the experiments had been honest, all they would have demonstrated would have been natural selection anyway, which is not the same as evolution

2. Live Birth in Three-toed Skinks

These skinks are purportedly moving from egg shelled birth to purely live birth. While that might be true, there is reason to question it. Even in the populations that lay the eggs that take the longest to hatch, the “eggshell” is more of a thin membrane than a shell. What this appears to be is an epigenetic adaptation to the intake of dietary calcium. If a population takes in enough calcium, lays eggs. If not, epigenetics kicks in, and the babies are born live. That’s a hypothesis but it’s a reasonable one. I’ll be doing more digging around on these skinks and a full article on them may come out in the future.

3. Interaction between Crabs and Mussels

This one is pretty interesting as well. A certain species of mussel has learned that a particular species of crab is a threat. In areas where this crab is found, the mussels notice the crab and thicken their shells accordingly. It’s a fascinating example of the interplay between predator and prey…but it’s not evolution. Learning can be passed from one generation to the next.  So a population of mussels has learned that this particular type of crab is the enemy and responds accordingly. That’s adaptation, not evolution.

4. Italian Wall Lizards 

This one is very interesting. Researchers performed an experiment where they took these lizards and placed them on an island where they essentially lacked predators. When the researchers returned after thirty years, they found that the population had grown dramatically, and changed nearly as much. They had adapted to the new habitat and the new diet remarkably well. However, their DNA was still very similar to the parent population, indicating that this was an adaptation, not an evolution. Because the DNA had not changed substantially, researchers could not argue that anything new was generated. Instead, what likely occurred was epigenetic.

5. Cane Toads

This example frankly is really a stretch. And by stretch, I mean an absolute desperate leap into the dark. Cane toads are native to the Americas but have been introduced to Australia where they are a pest. The population in Australia has slightly longer legs on average and is slightly tougher than the American population. The mere fact that this is being used as evidence of evolution proves how utterly bankrupt the hypothesis is.  Slightly longer legs are not evidence of either form of evolution. I’m not even sure it counts as evidence of adaptation. It’s just variation within the cane toad species.

We will continue walking through this list over the next few weeks. Trust me, it only gets worse from here, and this week contained a deliberate fraud. Unfortunately, that is what much of the popular level evidence for evolution is reduced to: frauds, misrepresentations, and reaches. As we move through this list, expect to see much more of the same.


Do you know what’s going to happen when you die? Are you completely sure? If you aren’t, please read this or listen to this. You can know where you will spend eternity. If you have questions, please feel free to contact us, we’d love to talk to you.


1 Comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s